top of page
  • Writer's pictureAI Law

Delayed Development: Origins of English Conflict of Laws

English conflict of laws emerged tardily compared to other legal branches, initially receiving scant attention. Blackstone's Commentaries on English Law notably omitted any reference to this field, reflecting its peripheral status. Courts were initially hesitant to adjudicate cases involving international elements, restricting themselves to matters solely connected with England. The emergence of commercial courts handling trade disputes did not constitute a conflict of laws, as foreign and domestic laws were not concurrently applied.

Shifts in Legal Landscape: From Reluctance to Recognition

The recognition of cases containing foreign elements gained traction post-1603, following the accession of James I, unifying England and Scotland under a common monarch. Initially, disputes focused on the recognition and enforcement of foreign decisions, with landmark cases like those concerning the validity of foreign marriages setting precedent. English judicial practice was significantly influenced by Ulrich Huber's theory of international courtesy of states, ushering in a new era of legal discourse.

Influential Legal Scholarship: The Contributions of Albert Van Dees

In 1896, Albert Van Dees published his seminal work, "Digests of English Law on Conflict Law," which marked a significant milestone in the development of English private international law. Dees challenged prevailing legal paradigms, advocating for a systematic approach to address conflicts arising from international legal interactions. His critique of Ulrich Huber's doctrine underscored the complexities inherent in enforcing foreign law within domestic legal frameworks.

The Legal Doctrine of A.V. Dicey: Shaping Modern Perspectives

A.V. Dicey's theory of rights further refined the understanding of English private international law, emphasizing the extraterritorial enforcement of rights acquired under the laws of civilized countries. His formulation laid the groundwork for future legal interpretations, asserting the principles guiding the recognition and enforcement of rights by English courts.

Codification and Reform: The Modernization of English Private International Law

Until the 1960s, English international private law primarily developed through judicial practice, with limited legislative foundations. Acts such as those in 1868, 1920, and 1933 addressed aspects of recognizing and enforcing foreign judgments but lacked comprehensive regulations for private international law. Since the 1960s, the adoption of international and domestic instruments has provided the necessary legal framework to navigate cross-border disputes, becoming the main sources of English private international law.

Conclusion: From Neglect to Recognition

The evolution of English private international law reflects a journey marked by shifts in legal perspectives and the gradual recognition of its significance in a globalized world. From its humble origins to its modern prominence, English private international law continues to play a pivotal role in fostering harmonious legal interactions across borders, underscoring the adaptability of legal systems to meet the demands of an interconnected world.

14 views0 comments


bottom of page